The Florida House of Representatives has launched its public redistricting website, and lawmakers are getting to work drawing congressional boundaries that comply (lawsuits notwithstanding) with two new constitutional amendments intended to require geographically compact districts that don’t favor or disfavor political parties, racial groups or incumbents.

Some legislative leaders — including Senate President Mike Haridopolos — have contended that the amendments create a difficult standard to meet: Just what is a “Fair District”?

One measure of a district’s fairness is its compactness, and the software firm Azavea has a website that measures it by four commonly used standards.

Two of the measures test how far a district is spread from its center: Is it drawn as tightly as possible, or does it wind its way from Jacksonville to Orlando? The other two test the smoothness of a district’s boundaries: Is it a neat square, or a contorted blob with amoeba-like appendages jutting out to grab convenient blocks of voters?

The site offers comparisons of individual districts and states as a whole. Low scores may indicate gerrymandering. Of the 43 states with multiple congressional representatives, Florida ranks third in the test of districts’ spread, and 10th and seventh on the two scales measuring smoothness.

Some of Florida’s lowest-scoring districts include the 22nd, currently represented by Allen West, R-Fort Lauderdale. A jagged “swing” district carved along the South Florida coast, it ranks among the five lowest scores.

Florida’s 3rd district, represented by Corrine Brown, D-Jacksonville, which snakes from Orlando to Jacksonville and touches Gainesville along the way, ranks eighth by one measure of its spread, and just outside the top 10 on the other three measures.

The 18th district, represented by Ileana Ros-Lehtinen, R-Miami, scores poorly by one of the measures, but geography probably plays a role: Her district includes the Florida Keys, which stretch its boundaries away from the center of an otherwise compact district.

Azavea points out on the site’s FAQ that compactness is not a perfect measure of fairness. Drawing perfectly compact districts could benefit the majority party or exclude minorities from representation (a key contention in Brown’s lawsuit challenging the Fair Districts amendments):

A number of scholars have suggested that compactness measures are best used not as absolute standards against which a single district’s shape is judged, but rather as a way to assess the relative merits of various proposed plans. Above all, compactness is most meaningful within the framework of an institutional redistricting process.

0 Shares:
Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like

Catholic groups spent millions supporting anti-gay marriage efforts: News. Politics. Media

The Knights of Columbus, a Catholic fraternal society founded in New Haven, Conn. in 1881, does a lot of good work. In a report detailing its charitable giving during 2009, the organization noted that while the “Knights and their families are hardly immune to the economic downturn,” they had once again furthered their proud 128-year tradition of service — a tradition including “helping the widows and orphans of the late 19th century” and “providing coats to poor, cold children.” Add to that list a donation of a whopping $1.4 million in 2009 to the National Organization for Marriage (NOM), a nonprofit group dedicated to fighting same-sex marriage through the ballot initiative system in California, Maine and other states. While NOM hasn’t yet made public its 2009 fundraising numbers, the amount of charitable contributions it received in 2008 totaled approximately $2.9 million.

Wisconsin group alleges ‘Disney-style’ tactics by United Way, Planned Parenthood

A Wisconsin group is alleging that United Way and Planned Parenthood are in cahoots in an effort to draw young girls into abortion facilities in the state. In an article published on OneNewsNow, Virginia Zignego of Pro-Life Wisconsin says that United Way is helping to further the cover-up of stauatory rape by placing colorful posters at various bus stops throughout the state.

Proposed ‘Religious Freedom’ amendment could complicate separation of church and state

An amendment repealing an existing ban on state funding for religious institutions in the state constitution is slated to appear on Florida's 2012 ballot. The controversial amendment is being promoted as a way to ensure religious freedom in the state, but the religious community is divided on whether the amendment will ensure religious freedom or threaten its sovereignty.

Update: Huckabee-affiliated anti-health care reform group fires scam artist: News. Politics. Media

The chairman of Restore America's Voice issued a statement to media outlets yesterday following reports by Think Progress and The Florida Independent that highlighted the fact that the PAC's Repeal it Now anti-health care reform campaign was being managed by Derek Oberholtzer of 949 Media Group, a scam artist made infamous for his Apply 2 Save foreclosure relief program that defrauded distressed homeowners nationwide.