Florida Secretary of State Kurt Browning told reporters Thursday that the bill doesn’t negatively impact Florida voters, and where the impact is, I believe it’s justified. We believe that this is a good bill, that this certainly closes up some gaps in our code, he said.
About an hour after Gov. Rick Scott quietly approved a controversial set of changes to Florida’s election laws, the state’s top elections official came to the measure’s defense.
In the days leading up to the signing of the bill, Scott had said repeatedly that he didn’t want to make it harder for people to vote. His office was flooded with messages warning the measure would do just that.
Florida Secretary of State Kurt Browning told reporters Thursday that the bill “doesn’t negatively impact Florida voters, and where the impact is, I believe it’s justified.”
“We believe that this is a good bill, that this certainly closes up some gaps in our code,” he said.
The bill has to be approved by the U.S. Department of Justice for five Florida counties – Collier, Hardee, Hendry, Hillsborough, and Monroe – that have a history of voter discrimination. Browning said his team is working on submitting the measure for federal approval. In the state’s remaining counties (including Miami-Dade, where an election is currently in progress), the measure will take effect immediately.
Here’s how Browning responded to some of the key criticisms of the measure:
Fewer days of early voting could be costly for supervisors of elections. The measure shortens the number of early voting days from 14 to eight but allows supervisors to maintain the total number of hours by extending the number of hours offered during each day of early voting.
Some supervisors of elections, including Ion Sancho of Leon County, have warned that the measure would increase the cost of early voting if they want to maintain the number of hours because it would require them to pay poll workers overtime.
“I respectfully disagree with my colleagues that will use the cost card,” said Browning, who previously served as the Pasco County Supervisor of Elections. He said supervisors could hire people for multiple 8-hour shifts to avoid incurring overtime costs, and that the changes will reduce the burden on supervisors in rural counties.
Making it more difficult for voters to change their addresses at the polls could mean their votes aren’t counted. Browning said his lawyers have advised him that this provision, which is among the most contentious, will likely pass muster under federal law. He also said he would be issuing a directive that would require local canvassing boards to count valid provisional ballots unless there is evidence of fraud, which will likely alleviate some of the concern about this provision.
Rep. Mark Pafford, D-Lake Worth, had offered an amendment to the measure on the floor of the Florida House that would have added language to the bill that said: “All valid provisional ballots must be counted before the election is certified.” That amendment was rejected along party lines.
New regulations on voter registration groups would make it more difficult to sign up new voters. The League of Women Voters of Florida said it may have to end its voter registration operations if the bill became law. Browning said the new law makes two major changes: it requires groups to register volunteers that sign up new voters and shortens the deadline for turning in registration forms from ten days to 48 hours -neither of which is overly onerous.
“We want Floridians to register to vote, and we want folks that want to register voters to vote to be able to have the opportunity to do that,” he said.
Jessica Lowe-Minor of the League of Women Voters said the group may still have to halt its voter registration operations based on the way the measure is worded, because it creates new hassles for volunteers (requiring them to enter identifying information in a state database and swear an oath they will comply with state election laws), and increases the group’s chances of facing fines (which remain capped at $1,000).
Many of the details – including the exact processes for regulating voter registration groups – will still have to be hammered out over the coming months. Groups like the League are weighing plans for lawsuits if the measure does get cleared by the Justice Department.
Sen. Miguel Diaz de la Portilla, who helped carry the measure through the Legislature, said in a statement that the bill “helps ensure that voters properly register and head to the polls at the right time” and “tightens regulations surrounding third-party groups to ensure voter fraud is kept to a minimum.”
“Governor Scott and the anti-civil liberties State Legislature have achieved an astonishing voter suppression trifecta,” Howard Simon, executive director of the ACLU of Florida, said in a statement. “With just one bill, they made it harder to register to vote, harder to cast your vote, and harder to have your vote counted.”
“This bill is an egregious attempt by misguided state legislators to suppress the voting rights of women, minorities, and the poor by forcing them to jump through excessive hoops to exercise their constitutional right to vote,” said a statement from Adora Obi Nweze, president of the Florida State Conference of the NAACP.
Browning said much of the outpouring of opposition to the measure was based on “misinformation,” fueled in part by “independent blogs” that were “working people up over things that they don’t necessarily need to be worked up over.” He said some of the provisions, such as the new restrictions on voter registration groups, may not prove to be as onerous as the bill’s opponents are claiming.
“All I know is what I read in the bill, and my many, many years of experience, and what I believe the outcome of this bill will be on Florida voters and the elections process,” he said. “And I’m just going to leave it at that.”
Note: An earlier version of this article stated that Rep. Pafford’s amendment had failed in a voice vote. It actually failed along party lines in a recorded vote, which we link to above. We regret the error.
Though many pro-life elected officials have attempted to distance themselves from Florida's fetal personhood amendment, which would outlaw abortions and some forms of birth control, state Rep. Charles Van Zant, R-Palatka, filed a bill in late January that shares some common language with Personhood Florida's proposed law.